Skip to content

Internal Shares Tying Executive Compensation to Company Performance

Phantom stock, also known as "shadow stock," is an alternative form of rewarding employees without actually issuing them stock or causing dilution for other shareholders. This plan shares many similarities with traditional stock options but offers unique advantages as explained below. So, what...

Ghost Shares: A Hidden Asset Type
Ghost Shares: A Hidden Asset Type

Internal Shares Tying Executive Compensation to Company Performance

Startups face numerous challenges when it comes to raising capital, but one solution that has gained traction is equity compensation. One such form of equity compensation is Phantom Equity, also known as shadow stock.

Phantom Equity is a type of deferred compensation offered by start-up companies to key employees or independent contractors. Unlike traditional equity, Phantom Equity does not allocate actual shares, making it an attractive option for startups looking to avoid equity dilution and maintain stock value.

For startups, the advantages of a Phantom Equity plan are numerous. Firstly, since no equity is transferred, founders and existing owners maintain full control over the company. Additionally, employers only recognize tax liability when they pay out Phantom Equity benefits, allowing them to design and change plan parameters as needed. This flexibility can be particularly beneficial for startups in their early stages.

However, there are also disadvantages to consider. Phantom Equity payouts are expenses that require cash reserves, which can potentially strain cash flow, especially in early-stage startups. Moreover, the company must account for potential future payouts on its balance sheet, which can affect financial planning.

For employees, the advantages of Phantom Equity include the ability to benefit from the company's performance without owning actual shares or dealing with the complexities that come with them. Additionally, Phantom Equity payments are reported as ordinary income on W-2s, unlike actual shares which may require K-1 forms if the business operates in multiple states.

However, employees do not gain voting rights or dividends like actual shareholders, potentially reducing their sense of ownership. Moreover, payments from Phantom Equity are taxed as ordinary income, often at a higher rate than capital gains tax applicable to real shares.

In summary, Phantom Equity plans allow startups to incentivize employees with stock-like benefits without diluting equity or transferring control, but they require careful management of cash flow and create ordinary income tax liabilities for employees rather than capital gains treatment.

Equity compensation can align the interests of employees with those of the company and its investors, making it a valuable tool for startups looking to attract and retain top talent. However, the tax implications of equity compensation can be complex, and it's essential for startups and employees to understand the advantages and disadvantages before implementing a Phantom Equity plan.

Read also:

Latest